Hidden Gem Romance books You Haven’t Heard Of (But Absolutely Should)

There’s nothing quite like finding a romance novel that feels like your little secret. You know the ones—the books that make you swoon, giggle, gasp, and possibly clutch your chest like a dramatic Victorian heroine. 

While the big-name romances get plenty of love, today I’m going to introduce you to some romance books you haven’t heard of—hidden gems that deserve way more hype. Oh, and because I know spice levels are important, I’m ranking these on the Flame-o-Meter.  

Here are some under-the-radar romance novels that deserve a spot on your TBR.

For Her Consideration

by Amy Spalding

Why It’s a Hidden Gem: A lesbian rom-com with a Hollywood setting, full of flirty banter, found family, and heartwarming moments.

Flame-o-Meter: 🔥🔥 (Moderate) – Some steamy moments, but the romance is more about the emotional connection.

Nina has sworn off relationships after a messy breakup, focusing instead on ghostwriting for Hollywood stars. Enter Ari, a charming actress who makes Nina question everything about her "no-dating" policy. This book is adorable, full of humor, and perfect for fans of sweet but satisfying sapphic romances.

Chick Magnet

by Emma Barry

Why It’s a Hidden Gem: A small-town romance featuring a grumpy veterinarian and a sunshine-y social media influencer who rescues chickens—need I say more?

Flame-o-Meter: 🔥🔥🔥 (Feeling Hot Hot Hot) – The heat builds deliciously between them.

Nicole is a popular online influencer who moves to a small town to recover from a rough breakup, bringing her chickens with her. Will, the local vet, is not thrilled about her presence—until their chemistry becomes impossible to ignore. This is a perfect mix of opposites-attract, found family, and heartwarming romance.

The Boyfriend Candidate

by Ashley Winstead

Why It’s a Hidden Gem: A bookish woman and a hot Texas politician fake-date their way into real feelings in this swoony, smart rom-com.

Flame-o-Meter: 🔥🔥🔥 (Feeling Hot Hot Hot) – The tension and chemistry are off the charts.

When shy librarian Alexis has a one-night stand with Logan, she doesn’t expect it to turn into a full-blown fake relationship for political optics. But as they spend more time together, their flirty banter turns into something real. It’s sharp, funny, and full of heart—ideal for fans of witty, modern romances.

Something Wild & Wonderful

by Anita Kelly

Why It’s a Hidden Gem: A tender, queer romance set on the Pacific Crest Trail—perfect for lovers of slow-burn love stories and outdoor adventure.

Flame-o-meter: 🔥🔥 (Moderate) – Emotional intimacy takes center stage, but there are some steamy moments.

Alexei and Ben meet while hiking the PCT, both at turning points in their lives. As they travel together, sharing stories under the stars and helping each other through challenges, their connection deepens. This book is a love letter to self-discovery, nature, and the quiet moments where love sneaks up on you.

The Sweetheart Deal

by Miranda Liasson

Why It’s a Hidden Gem: A small-town, marriage-of-convenience romance with a dash of family rivalry and plenty of slow-burn chemistry.

Flame-o-meter: 🔥🔥 (Moderate) – Some steam, but it’s mostly about the emotional connection.

Tessa’s family bakery is struggling, and rival chef Leo has a bold solution—a six-month marriage to merge their businesses. It’s strictly business ... until real feelings start to rise, making them question if they’ve found the perfect recipe for love. If you love Hallmark-movie vibes with a bit of heat, this one’s for you!

The romance genre has so many incredible stories that fly under the radar, and these are just a few that deserve all the love. Whether you’re in the mood for slow burn, laugh-out-loud moments, or angst, there’s a book on this list that will absolutely steal your heart.

Now tell me—what’s your favorite underrated romance? Drop your recommendations in the comments! I’m always on the hunt for my next bookish obsession.

Happy reading!

Eve x

I might be biased, but nothing quite matches the thrill of the Techboys Series. You can check out all the books in the series: The Refusal, The Outcast, The Secret, The Photograph, and The Game.

#evemriley #amyspalding#mirandaliasson #anitakelly #ashleywinstead #emmabarry #andrewseangreer #mustread #sexscenes #bestsexscenes #eroticromance #romancebooks #romancenovels #janusandjo #iwantajanus #therefusal #technologyromance #techboys #techromance #techhero #ireadromance #booklaunch #selfpublished #arc #amreading #romancereader #romancenovel #indieauthor #newauthor #newbook #newbookalert #newbooks #bookrelease #bookbuzz #debutnovel #bookrecommendations #romancebook #booklover #bookstagram #romancebookstagram #goodreads #amazonbestseller #bestseller #bestromancenovels #mmromance #love